I've visited 5 or 6 times, and it's consistently great! I love the texture of the crust and the creativity of the pizza creations. They also have a solid craft beer offering.
New York-style pizzeria in Sheboygan offering pizza by the slice or whole pie
Uptown Slice is a New York-style pizzeria in Sheboygan, serving pizza by the slice or as whole pies, alongside salads, sandwiches, desserts, and beverages. Our team offers a daily Flavor of the Day pizza, and at the Depot location, we also provide craft beer, wine, THC beverages, non-alcoholic cocktails, and locally made gelato and tiramisu.
I've visited 5 or 6 times, and it's consistently great! I love the texture of the crust and the creativity of the pizza creations. They also have a solid craft beer offering.
The pizza, the place, my experience. First the place, nothing special it's small. Perfect for pickup and deliveries. Ordered carryout on the app. The staff was friendly, paid for my pie and left. The pizza, i like giant 18" pies. The toppings were generous and the pizza was very good. My only thing is i didn't like was the dough. For me there was to much chew. The crust itself was quite chewy. Now i did take it home and it is a bit of a drive so the steam in the box I'm guessing created this. Maybe if i had Uptown slice cook my pizza a bit longer it may have helped, I like my pizza a bit more overdone. I will definitely be back to try another pizza. The price in my opinion is fair for this size pizza and toppings or no toppings. I forgot to add that i picked my order up from the 8th street location.
🍕 This pizza had me SPEECHLESS... 😳🔥 Uptown Slice Pizza delivers more than just great pizza. They offer indoor and outdoor seating, a clean restroom, free water with cups available, a full bar, and a different Flavor of the Day pizza every day. 💰 Most slices are around $5 each, making it an affordable option for a quick lunch or dinner. Was it worth the hype? Watch until the end and let me know what you'd rate it! 👇 📍 Uptown Slice Pizza #PizzaReview #UptownSlice #FoodReview #WisconsinEats #PizzaTok #Foodie #CheesePull #FoodieFinds #SupportLocal #PizzaLover #RestaurantReview #FoodContent #ViralFood #FYP #ForYouPage #Trending #FoodTok #HiddenGem #SliceOfPizza #MustTry
If you want a New York slice of pie Uptown Slice is the place! You can order by the slice or a whole pie. I ordered a slice of mushroom, mozzarella with truffle balsamic glaze and the cheese garlic bread. So good!
The pizza is 10/10. My husband is from NY and I have had so much good food and pizza being from California. This place has the best slices and my family and I will definitely be eating here again
Local time · GMT-6

While you're here
Everything local in Sheboygan, all in one place.

Fresh take and bake pizzas with Wisconsin cheese in Sheboygan

Serving milk tea, bubble tea, and custom drinks in Sheboygan

Serving butter burgers, cheese curds, and chicken strips in Sheboygan

Offering Asian dishes like Papaya Salad, Nam Khao, and Pho in Sheboygan

Wood-fired Neapolitan pizzeria, wine bar, deli, and Italian grocery

Old-timey railroad-themed eatery for broaster chicken and draft beer

American comfort food served in our rustic forest cabin
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with Uptown Slice
Claim it free to post events and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.
Claim this listing