West Allis Fish Fry: Kegel's Since 1924 and Two Supper Clubs

A 1924 Tudor Revival dining room on National Avenue, two supper clubs within about six miles, and the Friday habit behind all of them.

The fish fry West Allis has served since 1924 is a sit-down meal in a dining room walled in painted murals, a long way from a paper-lined basket. Kegel's Inn, at 5901 West National Avenue, opened in 1924 and still serves a Friday fish fry. Two supper clubs within about six miles, Buckatabon in Wauwatosa and Clifford’s in Hales Corners, round out the choices.

Kegel's Inn: the 1924 fish fry on National Avenue

Kegel's Inn is a sit-down restaurant with a bar room and an adjoining dining room. Its Friday fish fry rates above average and in the top tier of Milwaukee-area fish fries, though not the best.

Sponsored

Google lists the Friday fish fry at Kegel's Inn from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.

A 2026 local roundup also lists Wednesdays, 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., and strongly recommends reservations; Google shows shorter weekday hours, so call before planning a midweek visit.

One Google reviewer calls the place busy and another recommends reserving for a Friday night.

The same roundup lists cod, lake perch, walleye, bluegill, grouper and catfish, plus a 3-2-1 platter of three cod, two perch and one walleye fillet. An undated Milwaukee Record review describes homemade potato pancakes and German potato salad as side options, with spaetzle or a dumpling as a swap for the potato, and caraway rye bread on the table, so details may have changed. One Google reviewer preferred the potato pancakes to the fries.

Service gets mixed reviews when the room is full: one Google reviewer praised fast service, while another waited 15 minutes for a server to offer drinks on a busy night.

The family says the business opened on December 5, 1924, as a Prohibition-era soda parlor with beer brewed in the basement. Julian Kegel is the fourth generation to run it. The current building dates to 1933, and its Tudor Revival style, stone veneer and interior murals by the German-born artist Peter Gries helped earn a place on the National Register of Historic Places in 2010. The restaurant also has a year-round beer garden called Bootleggers Alley.

How the Milwaukee-area fish fry got its plate

The Friday fish fry grew out of Catholic Friday abstinence from meat, and Prohibition-era taverns turned it into a weekly habit. Historians including John Gurda point to Jones Island in the 1860s and 1870s, where Kashubian fishing families settled, as the fish fry's ground zero. During Prohibition, tavern owners sold fish lunches, especially on Fridays, to draw families in. In the mid-1960s the Church limited the Friday rule to Lent, but Friday fish was already a Wisconsin custom. Fish fries are still eaten more often during Lent.

The standard plate is fish, potatoes, coleslaw and rye bread, with lemon wedges, malt vinegar or tartar sauce on the side. Milwaukee has its own set of Friday fish fry spots, including the Lent drive-thrus, if you want to compare.

Two supper clubs within about six miles

Buckatabon in Wauwatosa is about 2.5 miles from Kegel's Inn in a straight line, and Clifford's in Hales Corners is about 6 miles. Both fit the Wisconsin supper club mold, and the Milwaukee supper clubs worth lining up for include a few more.

Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club, also called Frank & Larry's Buckatabon, sits at 7700 Harwood Avenue in Wauwatosa and is modeled on the family-run Northwoods restaurants of the 1940s through the 1960s. It serves a fish fry every day, with house-made potato pancakes. Google lists it open until 11 p.m. on Fridays. Reviewers mention a riverside setting among cobblestone streets and twinkle lights. Brandy Old Fashioneds are a draw; OnMilwaukee counted five versions on the menu in 2024.

Clifford’s Supper Club at 10418 West Forest Home Avenue has been family-owned since it opened in 1959 and serves a fish fry daily. Friday is all-you-can-eat, and a 2026 roundup lists all-you-can-eat fried Iceland cod seven days a week. Relish plates are available on request. Google lists it closed Sundays and Mondays, with Friday service until 10 p.m. and Saturday opening at 3 p.m. A 2014 Shepherd Express review described dark wood paneling and a Formica-topped bar, and reviewers on Google call the interior dated, with one noting a 3 percent credit card surcharge.

Which fish to order

Travel Wisconsin lists perch, walleye, haddock, cod and bluegill as the usual fish on a Wisconsin fish fry plate. At Kegel's Inn, the Milwaukee Record review noted a baked cod and a jumbo shrimp option for anyone who skips the fryer, though the menu may have changed since. If you cannot decide, the 3-2-1 platter at Kegel's puts cod, perch and walleye on one plate. The Clifford's entry in the same roundup names Iceland cod, so a perch fan should call ahead.

What else is on the table at Kegel's

OnMilwaukee describes Kegel's as a German heritage bar and restaurant, with German beer and food beyond the fish. Its centennial weekend in December 2024 featured hors d'oeuvre stations of duck nests, tenderloin goulash and wiener schnitzel. The head server has worked there since 1984. A mural scavenger hunt ran during the centennial weekend. One Google reviewer recommends a pretzel, a wurst and cheese curds to start.

Planning a West Allis fish fry night

Book Kegel's Inn ahead for a Friday, since a 2026 roundup strongly recommends reservations and one Google reviewer recommends reserving for a Friday night. Clifford's runs the all-you-can-eat plate on Fridays. One 2026 roundup also lists The Brass Monkey on West Greenfield Avenue in West Allis, which it says serves fish fry until 2:30 a.m., so check hours before a late run. Pair dinner with a walk through things to do in West Allis and the evening fills out.

Kegel's posts reservation pointers on its website, kegelsinn.com.

Whichever table you take, the plate starts the way it did in the Prohibition taverns: fish, potatoes, slaw and rye.

Frequently asked questions

Published August 17, 2026

You might also like

See all