Ordered the Santa Fe BBQ chicken pizza on 6/23/26. One of the best BBQ chicken pizzas I've ever had! The location is very cool as well.
Creative pizzas and classic pastas in Sun Prairie
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. is a pizza restaurant in Sun Prairie.
Ordered the Santa Fe BBQ chicken pizza on 6/23/26. One of the best BBQ chicken pizzas I've ever had! The location is very cool as well.
Our usual local pizza place was closed, so we grabbed carry-out from Glass Nickel—and they totally saved the night! Huge thanks to the staff; even though it was right before closing, they were incredibly sweet and easygoing. The pizza was outstanding, just like always. Bonus points: Glass Nickel pizza is one of the few that tastes just as amazing cold or reheated the next day. Highly recommend! 🍕🔥
I just had dinner with my two girls (5 & 2) and was pleasantly surprised by the service! We order Glass Nickle all the time and the pizza has always been delicious, but this was our first time actually at the establishment in forever. I wish I would have gotten the workers names, but a women came out with chalk for the girls to color on the patio while I was able to enjoy a cocktail, instead of think of a thousand ways to entertain them waiting for food without an iPad. Our server was a middle aged man who was very attentive and quick to any needs of ours. We will definitely be dining in again! What could have been a nightmare as a single mom with two young children out to eat, turned out to be a great experience. (Minus the 2 year old tripping and scraping her knee at the end of the meal).
Local time · GMT-6

While you're here
Everything local in Sun Prairie, all in one place.

Traditional pizza with locally sourced toppings

1950s-style diner with a classic chrome exterior

American comfort food, Friday fish fry, and live music

Mexican dishes, margaritas, and murals on Prairie Lakes Drive

Mexican dining and takeout on West Main Street

Serving baked and bake-at-home pies in Sun Prairie

French-inspired bistro with escargots, halibut, and Basque cheesecake

Madison supper club offering a full menu, craft cocktails, and a large event space
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with Glass Nickel Pizza Co.
Claim it free to post events and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.
Claim this listing