We were able to sneak in as a walk in and so glad we did. Food was divine, service was great. Can't wait to return.
Upscale Italian fare from local ingredients in a casual space
Upscale Italian fare created from local ingredients & served in a casual, rustic space.
We were able to sneak in as a walk in and so glad we did. Food was divine, service was great. Can't wait to return.
First, our server, August, was excellent! To eat, my wife and I shared the carpaccio, which was fantastic. It had a bright, lemony flavor with fresh Parmesan, arugula, and some fresh pepper on top. The Rustika salad was great as well. The combination of gorgonzola and pecorino was incredible, especially paired with the roasted grapes and apples. It had that perfect mix of sweet, savory, and tangy. For entrées, my wife got the Della Nonna with in house made gluten free noodles, and I got the ossobuco which was delicious! The veal was incredibly tender and flavorful, and scooping out the bone marrow was a treat. I also loved the risotto on the side which was creamy and rich. For my dessert, I had the tiramisu, and it did not disappoint! It was super creamy with a perfectly soaked bottom layer, which is just the way I like it.
Just celebrated a birthday dinner and had excellent food and a great atmosphere. I also had a birthday in here 30 years ago, and the food has remained absolutely excellent, as the service has remained top-notch. It’s hard to find a restaurant that can continue a wonderful tradition of imaginative cuisine, excellent quality, and a comfortable atmosphere.
Enjoyed a New Years Eve dinner here! It was really wonderful overall. The place is cute, service is great. The food was a pre fix menu so I can’t speak for the regular menu. It was delicious, especially the Antipasti. Wine selection and cocktail list was extensive. The owner was present during dinner service, Whitney, which I loved! She’s personable and welcoming (support local). I would highly recommend this place to everyone visiting Kohler, it’s a 10 minute drive from the hotel properties.
Local time · GMT-6

While you're here
Everything local in Sheboygan, all in one place.

Fresh take and bake pizzas with Wisconsin cheese in Sheboygan

Serving milk tea, bubble tea, and custom drinks in Sheboygan

Serving butter burgers, cheese curds, and chicken strips in Sheboygan

Offering Asian dishes like Papaya Salad, Nam Khao, and Pho in Sheboygan

Wood-fired Neapolitan pizzeria, wine bar, deli, and Italian grocery

Old-timey railroad-themed eatery for broaster chicken and draft beer

American comfort food served in our rustic forest cabin
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with Trattoria Stefano
Claim it free to post events and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.
Claim this listing