About

Old World Creamery is a manufacturer in Sheboygan, creating a variety of cheese, butter, and dairy products. We have crafted dairy products from fine ingredients since 1912, a philosophy continued by our fourth-generation family-owned company. We manage all aspects of the business, from sourcing milk from local, family-owned dairy farms to manufacturing cheese in Wisconsin facilities. Our team imports Irish butter, grades it in-house, and packages it in Sheboygan for distribution.

J Vernon

5 months ago

This is a hidden gem! It’s so cute inside with antiques and Wisconsin decor. Great prices and friendly service especially on butter and cheese. It’s definitely worth a stop!

The Simple Life of CC

6 months ago

Cute little cheese shop. I usually buy their butter when I go and a spreadable cheese for crackers. Love the ice cream counter, great place to take the little ones for an inexpensive cone treat! Parking can be a bit tricky at times. You probably drive by it quite often not really knowing the store is there!

Darlene Henning

9 months ago

This was such a pleasant place to stop. The gentleman who help us did such a good job. The little store had a very good offering of things to buy and the prices were not out of line. Loved the antique decor as well.

Alexandra Fries

a year ago

I was blessed with some of the old world, creamery, unsalted butter. As a Chef, this butter was perfect for my classic French croissants. 100% would use again!

Old World Creamery

About

Reviews

Featured in

Sheboygan Brats: The Double, the Hard Roll, the Fry

Sheboygan Italian Restaurants (One Family Since 1994)

Frequently asked

Explore more of Sheboygan