We knew we wanted Bettersweet's carrot cake for our wedding and it did not disappoint! The cake was beautiful and delicious and Jen and team were super accommodating about the pick up! We'd definitely recommend :)
Custom-order bakery creating celebration desserts in Plymouth
Bettersweet Bakery is a custom-order bakery in Plymouth, Wisconsin. We create desserts intended to be the centerpiece of celebrations. Our bakery crafts unique designs for wedding cakes and cupcakes. We have been creating custom cakes for nearly two decades. We started in a rented kitchen outside Elkhart Lake, baking for farmer's markets and taking initial wedding cake orders.
We knew we wanted Bettersweet's carrot cake for our wedding and it did not disappoint! The cake was beautiful and delicious and Jen and team were super accommodating about the pick up! We'd definitely recommend :)
We used Bettersweet for our wedding cake & dessert cupcakes for our guests, and could not have asked for a better experience! Both our wedding cake & cupcakes were delicious, and Jen made the whole experience stress free. She was great to work with and we loved our unique wedding cake design.
Excellent Bakery. Had them for our wedding in 2015 for Cake and Cupcakes and keep coming back for different cakes! Great food but make sure you call ahead!
Absolutely hands down the best wedding cake and cupcakes ever!! Our only regret is Jen recommended 3 mini cupcakes per person and we thought it was too much and we would have tons left over we were so incredibly wrong...we had signature butter frosting with raspberry filling, then we had caramel and marshmallow creme filling with cream cheese frosting as our wedding cake flavors, followed by orange cake with vanilla creme filling and signature butter frosting, lemon cake with vanilla creme filling and cream cheese frosting, classic chocolate cake with crushed chocolate creme filling and cream cheese frosting, and finally rainbow sprinkle cake with marshmallow creme filling and cream cheese frosting.. needless to say we had no cupcakes left and a couple of cake pieces left our guest were so complimentary of the dessert..thank you so much

While you're here
Everything local in Plymouth, all in one place.

Handcrafted sourdough breads and sweet treats from our microbakery

Freshly baked goods, coffee, and dog treats in Plymouth
Freshly baked goods and custom donuts in Plymouth

Breakfast sandwiches, handmade pastries, and specialty coffee drinks

Hand-crafted cheesecakes for individual and custom orders

Freshly baked turtle brownies and chocolate chip banana bread

Custom cinnamon rolls and pumpkin donuts in Sheboygan
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with Bettersweet Bakery
Claim it free to post events and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.
Claim this listing