I order a 12 pack late night. My order was missing 2 cookies. I am happy to say I called the store this morning and got my replacement cookies. Not sure if I spoke with a manager or just employee but I appreciate the good customer service.
Warm cookies, ice cream, and late-night deliveries
Bakery chain known for warm cookies, ice cream & late-night deliveries.
I order a 12 pack late night. My order was missing 2 cookies. I am happy to say I called the store this morning and got my replacement cookies. Not sure if I spoke with a manager or just employee but I appreciate the good customer service.
I went to this location during a time when they were restocking and they didnt have what i wanted (cookie dough cream) and im leavinf this review because insomnia cookies has always been ole reliable and I just so happen to be on a diet so thanks for being reliable even in this situation! I'll forever love IC!
Local time · GMT-6

While you're here
Everything local in Milwaukee, all in one place.

All-vegan, gluten-free pops and natural shaved ice in Milwaukee

Indulge in bubble waffles, croffles, and dessert cups in Milwaukee

Serving bubble waffle creations and dessert options until late in Milwaukee

Traditional Mexican ice cream and aguas frescas made with natural fruit

Family-owned drive-in serving housemade frozen custard and fast-food eats

Artisanal scoops and innovative flavors, including tasting flights

Self-serve frozen yogurt, Superfruit bowls, and coffee on Milwaukee's East Side

Serving ice cream, chicken, and fries daily in Milwaukee
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with Insomnia Cookies
Claim it free to post events and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.
Claim this listing