Serving pizza, burgers, and ice cream in a casual setting
Food is always delicious. The staff are always friendly and accommodating. I’ve held family parties in their back dining room, ordered take out for home and we order pizzas weekly for our summer camp programs at P&R. Theo and his wife are very generous and support our community in many ways.
I've been coming to Pies & Pub for a few years now, and one thing that always stands out is Sue. She's consistently friendly, welcoming, and genuinely great at what she does. In fact, for the longest time I assumed she was the owner because she cares so much about the guests and the overall experience. The food is always good, but people like Sue are what keep customers coming back. Pies & Pub is lucky to have her. Highly recommend!
I’m in town for work and did a search for pizza near me. Liked the reviews for this place so I gave it a try. Ordered a meat lovers pizza and added jalapeño and black olives. Also went for hot buffalo wings. Ordered ahead on the website for a 4:30 pickup. Website was very user friendly and made the process easy. When I arrived I was immediately struck by the incredible aroma of a wood fire that was amazing and made me very excited. I arrived early so I did have to wait a few minutes. My order was ready on time and correct. The pizza and wings were both incredible and I would highly recommend this place to anyone. It had a nice neighborhood vibe going on at the bar and all the employees were very nice. Overall a great experience. I bought the wine at a nearby shop that I would also recommend.
I love Pies & Pub! The atmosphere is always upbeat and friendly. The bar area is always full of energy and the seating outside is airy, bright and full of nature. All of the staff are friendly, kind, and they pay attention to detail. I love how they all work together. Their food is fantastic! I am a huge fan of their pizza lightly cooked on the crust, their meatballs, french fries, mac n cheese and dessert case! I travel 40 minutes for a visit! I highly recommend. 👍😃👍
Local time · GMT-5
While you're here
Everything local in Middlebury, all in one place.
Modern dining in a historic setting, featuring Italian-inspired fusion dishes
Fresh roasted coffee, deli selections, and gourmet baked goods
Serving breakfast and brunch dishes with freshly squeezed orange juice
Italian deli with ravioli and meatballs in Middlebury
Serving American Chinese food classics and sushi in Middlebury
Serving bagels with cream cheese, coffee, and smoothies in Middlebury
Italian restaurant serving fresh food for over 24 years in Middlebury
American restaurant in Middlebury serving grilled salmon, calamari, and cocktails
Is this your business?
Reach people across town and nearby with Pies & Pub (formerly Pies & Pints)
Claim it free to post events and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.
Claim this listing