That's Amore

Restaurant · ItalianGreenfield, WisconsinHours

An extensive menu of Italian classics in a retro spot

About

Welcoming spot with comfortable booths & a retro vibe serving an extensive menu of Italian classics.

Pete G
a month ago

Had a family dinner here for the first time, well worth the 1.5hr drive! Nice atmosphere and decor, friendly staff with great service. Tried the Seafood Amore as I don't eat much seafood and always like to try something new. Also had a Dino Cheesesteak reheated for lunch the next day, and I'll come back just to have another! Every dish was excellent and had great flavor, although the Seafood Amore was less seasoned and more on the plain side for my taste, but still good.

Darlene K
a month ago

First time here , and this is definitely on my list to come back to ! I just returned from oregon with its fresh seafood and ordered the seafood platter here. Definitely up to the taste and the freshness of oceanside food. We had an experienced waiter, Mary ,who knew what to ask, when to check on us , what to get and to make sure it was what we wanted. Depending on where you sit , the atmosphere is very cozy to open in chatty. We actually were not far from the front door at a table, and yet were able to interact and chat without any problem. There were three of us and we were all very satisfied with the food and hope you will be too! plus they have a great tiramisu !! Prices were reasonable.

Christi Peterson
2 months ago

I visitied That's Amore as a work lunch with coworkers. This is a good spot for a real Italian meal! Our waiter was nice and efficient! The tables in our area were a little snug to others, but did allow for elbow room. The salad was fresh! The dressing was ok, but I would have prefered more flavor; maybe some croutons would've helpped. The breadsticks were baked well and fresh, I personally would have prefered some garlic flavor. I also ordered the mushroom revioli... that was good! It had flavor in the sauce and the pasta was cooked well! Btw, this was the lunch portion, not the dinner one...portions are large! This is a place I would return to to try something new!

Savannah Wilber
6 months ago

We hosted our rehearsal dinner in the upstairs here on a busy Saturday evening the night before our wedding and I could not have been more impressed. The servers were friendly, attentive, and served our party in a very timely manner despite being a large group of 30 people. Our guests raved about the food! For a small fee, they also stored and served our cake which was greatly appreciated. Our rehearsal dinner truly could not have gone smoother and I’m so grateful to the That’s Amore staff for helping our wedding weekend go perfectly. I would absolutely recommend this space for any private events!

Theopolis Pennington
8 months ago

Yes, to everything! My first visit here will certainly not be my last! That's Amore far exceeded my expectations in every aspect. It's a beautiful building, with a charming atmosphere that makes you almost feel like you're home. From the moment we walked in, the hostess greeted us with a warm smile and made us feel welcome. The manager, Justin, came by to say hello, introduce himself, and to ensure we were being well taken care of, and that all of our needs were met. I was happy to report that his whole team had gone aove and beyond, in every aspect, and that we will certainly be returning! Our server, Angelo, did an exceptional job, huge props! He was very patient, attentive, helpful, and made excellent recommendations for some first time visitors. I took so long trying to decide what to have, everything on this menu looks incredible. Appetizer: Amore Combo - amazing HIGHLY RECOMMEND if you need some variety and can't pick just one. The whole thing was great, but the breaded bow tie pasta was my favorite, we loved the haystack onion rings - which were great when they "fell" in top of the salad. Salad: Fresh, bright. The dressing was so delicious we had to take some home! Bread sticks: perfectly baked, warm, seasoned, and with perfect texture. A delicious tool to capture all the delicious flavors in the sauces - no sauce left behind! Gnocchi: cheesy, saucy, perfectly cooked, with such a rich depth of flavor. Highly recommend! Vegetable Ravioli: My date is vegetarian, and there were plenty of options, this is what she chose. She loved it, and so did I! The ravioli are large, the sauce was rich and bright, and the vegetables were fresh and delicious! Dessert: New York Style Strawberry Cheesecake & Tiramisu - simply put - YES! Overall, without any hesitation, one of my favorite experiences, and definitely a new favorite date night spot for us. I'll add more to this review with future visits, I plan to eat my way through this menu.

Review us

Frequently asked

  • What are your hours?

    Local time · GMT-6

    • Monday11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
    • TuesdayClosed
    • Wed – Thu11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
    • Fri – Sat11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
    • Sunday11:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Greenfield

While you're here

Explore more of Greenfield

Everything local in Greenfield, all in one place.

  • Every event coming up, from markets to live music
  • Places to eat, stay and visit nearby
  • Local guides from people who know the area

Other Restaurants you might like

BURGER HUB
Greenfield
BURGER HUB

BURGER HUB

4.9(1085)Restaurant
Lebnani house
Greenfield
Lebnani house

Lebnani house

4.8(3141)Restaurant · Lebanese
Taqwas Bakery and Restaurant
Greenfield
Taqwas Bakery and Restaurant

Taqwas Bakery and Restaurant

4.8(2171)Restaurant · Mediterranean
Cheba Hut 'Toasted' Subs
Greenfield
Cheba Hut 'Toasted' Subs

Cheba Hut 'Toasted' Subs

4.8(182)Restaurant · American
Carrabba's Italian Grill
Greenfield
Carrabba's Italian Grill

Carrabba's Italian Grill

4.6(3955)Restaurant · Italian
Melt n Dip
Greenfield
Melt n Dip

Melt n Dip

4.6(788)Restaurant · French

Is this your business?

Reach people across town and nearby with That's Amore

Claim it free to post events and updates that show up on town pages, event calendars and local recommendations — and help local and AI search find you.

Claim this listing